Which sentence is punctuated correctly?

Understanding Punctuation in Dialogue

Punctuation plays a crucial role in writing, especially when it comes to dialogue. Correct punctuation in dialogue can make a significant difference in the clarity and flow of a conversation. Let's take a look at an example:

"Did you bring anything for the volunteers to eat?" asked Jack.

"Did you bring anything for the volunteers to eat?" asked Jack?

"Did you bring anything for the volunteers to eat?"? asked Jack.

The answer is the first one: "Did you bring anything for the volunteers to eat?" asked Jack.

Which sentence is punctuated correctly?

Answer: "Did you bring anything for the volunteers to eat?" asked Jack.

Explanation: The question mark is part of the dialogue, not the narration, therefore it should be included inside the quotation marks, not outside. Placing the question mark at the very end as in the second option is not only absurd, but it also leaves the interrogative structure "Did you bring" without its necessary question mark.

← Natural deduction exercise proving p from given premises The reflection of refugee experience →